Britain's EU vote in perspective and the Australia election: Shane Oliver

GUEST OBSERVER

 

The past week has been dominated by first the anticipation that Britain would vote to Remain within the EU that saw “risk on” in financial markets and shares rally followed by an abrupt move to “risk off” as the referendum saw the Leave vote win by 52 percent to 48 percent.

 

The vote to Leave poses risks: to the UK economy which will also face a period of political instability with PM Cameron to step down by October and pro-EU Scotland pushing for another independence referendum; to Eurozone stability over fears that some Eurozone countries may seek to follow the UK; and hence to global growth.

 

It also threatens to add momentum to a move away from economic rationalist policies in favour of populism and a reversal of globalisation which would be a negative for long term global growth.

Reflecting the worries about the impact on the UK and more significantly Europe financial markets reacted sharply in “risk off” fashion on Friday with the British pound (-8.1 percent), British shares (-3.1 percent), the Euro (-2.4 percent) and Eurozone shares (-8.6 percent) down sharply and this seeing global share markets down generally along with the Australian dollar. Safe haven assets such as bonds, the $US, Yen and gold have all benefitted.

 

This could have further to go in the short term until some of the dust settles. A concern is that a rising $US in response to safe haven demand will weigh on the Renminbi (sparking new fears of capital outflows from China), commodity prices and emerging countries taking us back to the global growth fears we saw earlier this year.

However, it’s worth putting all of this in perspective. First the moves in some markets seen on Friday were exaggerated because the moves that occurred during the first four days of the last week when markets thought Remain would win had to be reversed. So, for example, while Eurozone shares fell 8.6 percent on Friday they only fell 2.6 percent over the last week.

 

Over the week as a whole US shares lost 1.6 percent, Japanese shares lost 4.2 percent, Chinese shares fell 1.1 percent and Australian shares fell 1 percent. Bad but not monumental. Believe it or not the British share market actually rose 2 percent over the last week. While the British pound fell 8.1 percent on Friday it only fell 4.7 percent over the week as a whole and the $A actually rose 1 percent last week. It was similar with bonds and oil – big moves on Friday but only modest moves over the week

Second, Britain has only started down a process to exit and has a long way to go yet. It will first need a new PM then later this year formally notify its intent to exit which will then kick off a negotiation process that will then take up to two years to complete. This will determine the ultimate impact on the UK economy – either it will retain free trade access to the EU but have to continue to allow the free movement of people, agree to EU rules and regulations and contribute to its budget or forgo free trade altogether. At this stage its hard to see which way this will go. But the point is that for some time the UK will still be in the EU. 

Third, while the Brexit vote will likely trigger a guessing game as to which Eurozone country will try and follow its lead and ask for a similar referendum it’s doubtful that Eurozone countries will actually seek to leave because the hurdle to leave the Eurozone is higher than Britain leaving the EU as it will mean adopting a new currency, paying higher interest rates, etc. Just think of Greece despite its woes over the last few years consistently deciding to stay in the Eurozone. Countries to watch though are Italy following the recent success in municipal elections of the Eurosceptic Five Star Movement and maybe Spain given the success of Podemos.

Fourth, the Brexit vote is unlikely to be akin to a Lehman moment because conditions are radically different. Lehman came after a long period of global strength and a credit boom where liabilities and exposures were opaque. That is not the case now and Brexit has been talked about endlessly so is not the surprise Lehman was.

Finally, central banks have quickly adopted a “whatever is necessary” stance to provide liquidity to markets and support their economies, notably the Bank of England which is already providing £250bn. The ECB is monitoring the situation but its liquidity measures (eg TLTRO) are probably more than enough at present. The more important point is that global monetary policy will remain easier for longer. The Fed certainly will be slowed further in raising rates because it won’t want to put more upwards pressure on the $US which is being boosted by safe haven demand. A G7 Statement decrying excessive currency volatility has arguably given Japan close to a green light to intervene to stop the Yen rising much further. Expect more BoJ easing soon which should help Japanese shares.

I am not so confident about British assets given the long period of uncertainty the UK will now face both economically and politically. However, the global bout of “risk off” underway is likely to provide a buying opportunity as Europe is likely to hang together, global monetary policy is likely to be even easier than previously thought and the global economy is likely to continue to see modest growth.

Given that only 2.7 percent of Australian exports go to the UK and that the Leave victory is unlikely to plunge Europe into an immediate recession the main impact on Australia will be on financial markets. This could affect short term confidence and may add to the case for the RBA to cut interest rates again particularly if banks increase their mortgage rates out of cycle due to higher funding costs flowing from an increase in lender caution.

 

That said we expect the RBA to cut rates again anyway and a falling $A will continue to provide a shock absorber for the Australian economy. Overall, Brexit barely changes the risk of recession in Australia which remains low.

The key for investors is to either look through the short term noise caused by the Brexit decision or look for investment opportunities that it throws up as investment markets become oversold.

Just finally on Europe, the last week saw the German constitutional court approve the validity of the ECB's Outright Monetary Transaction (OMT) program, which partly underpins Draghi's 2012 commitment to do "whatever it takes" to preserve the Euro. This is a big relief because its rejection would have put a cloud over the ECB’s ability to respond to any turmoil in peripheral bond markets that may flow from the Brexit vote.

Now on to other things!

In Australia, the big event in the week ahead will be the Federal election (Saturday). Each side of politics is offering very different visions for the size of government:

 

Labor is focussed on spending more on health and education and in the process allowing the size of the public sector to increase, funded by tax increases on higher income earners (retention of the budget deficit levy and cutbacks in access to negative gearing, the capital gains tax discount and superannuation). The ALP would also undertake a royal commission into banking and intervention in the economy is likely to be higher than under a Coalition government.

By contrast the Coalition is focussed more on containing spending, and encouraging economic growth via company tax cuts and mild reforms. Despite the Coalition’s tilt to “fairness” with its super reforms it’s committed to keeping taxes down. It does plan to reinstate the Australian building & Construction Commission but even with the double dissolution election it’s unclear whether it will get enough votes to do this.

At this stage the polls suggest the Australian election is too close to call. But it’s a big ask to see the ALP become the first opposition in 85 years to regain government after just one term as it will need to win 19 seats. As such betting agencies have the Coalition as favourite. However, the big issue may be what happens in the Senate with there being a good chance that the Greens and minority “parties” control the balance of power again acting as a huge constraint on the government, which would mean another de facto minority government, ie more of the same. Which in turn mean poor prospects for getting government spending under control over the next three years and for implementing serious productivity enhancing economic reforms.

Over the 7 weeks since the election was called the Australian share market has fallen 3.1 percent. The next table shows that 8 out of 12 elections since 1983 saw shares up 3 months later with an average gain of 4.8 percent. This may partly reflect relief at getting the election out of the way.

 

 

Fed Chair Janet Yellen’s congressional testimony didn’t really add much. The key is that the Fed is “proceeding cautiously” to give it time to assess whether the US economy and inflation is on track with its expectations and given global uncertainties. Uncertainty and market turmoil flowing from the Brexit outcome is likely to further delay the Fed in terms of raising rates again.

US economic data was mostly good. While durable goods orders were weak, the June manufacturing PMI rose, home prices rose, home sales were strong, jobless claims fell sharply and home prices continue to rise. And the US’s top 33 banks passed a Fed stress test indicating that they have enough capital to withstand a severe economic shock (involving unemployment doubling to 10 percent.) In other words they are in good shape to withstand any shock flowing from Brexit.

The Eurozone composite business conditions PMI fell slightly in June with a decline in services (on Brexit fears?) offsetting a gain in manufacturing. It remains at a level consistent with moderate growth though.

Japan’s manufacturing conditions PMI rose just 0.1pt to a still weak 47.8 in June indicating that growth in June quarter is still struggling.

A couple of Chinese business conditions surveys moved in opposite directions for June with one up solidly and a small business PMI weakening. So bit of a wash there.

In Australia, the minutes from the last RBA Board meeting added little that was new with the RBA neutral and on the sidelines for now. However, our view remains that lower inflation and a too high $A on ongoing Fed delays will still see more easing ahead with the next cut likely in August. Meanwhile Australian economic data over the last week was uneventful. March quarter house prices fell slightly according to the ABS but more timely private sector data suggests a renewed pick up since then particularly in Sydney.

 

While population growth has slowed from its 2% peak late last decade to 1.4 percent last year it’s still contributing to solid underlying demand for housing. NSW and Victoria are the top states for population growth, and flowing partly from this house price growth. Which in turn partly explains the good state of their budgets. Finally, skilled vacancies continue to see reasonable growth telling us that the labour market remains solid.

The focus in the week ahead will no doubt see continued reaction to the Brexit referendum, particularly given an EU leaders’ summit on Tuesday and Wednesday.
In the US, expect to see a further gain in home prices and a slight rise in consumer confidence (Tuesday), solid growth in personal spending and a slight rise in the core private consumption deflator to 1.7 percent for the year to May, but a slight fall in pending home sales (all Wednesday) and a slight rise in the ISM manufacturing conditions index (Friday) to around 51.5 (Friday).

In the Eurozone expect bank lending (Monday) and economic confidence readings for June (Wednesday) to remain around levels consistent with continued moderate economic growth. Core inflation data for June (Thursday and unemployment data (both Friday) will also be released. The outcome of the Spanish election on Sunday may also add to short term uncertainties regarding the Eurozone.

In Japan, expect a slight fall in industrial production (Thursday), a deterioration in the June quarter Tankan survey reflecting the recent earthquake and continued softness in household spending but the jobs market (all Friday) is likely to remain solid helped by the falling workforce. Core inflation (also Friday) is expected to fall to 0.6 percent yoy in May.
In Australia, apart from Saturday’s election, expect the trend in new home sales (Wednesday) to remain modestly down, ABS job vacancies for the 3 months to May to rise consistent with monthly vacancy data and continued moderate credit growth (Thursday) and a slight softening in home price momentum in June (Friday) according to CoreLogic. The AIG’s manufacturing conditions PMI (Friday) will also be released.

The aftermath of the Brexit vote could see more volatility in shares in the short term. However, beyond near term uncertainties, we still see shares trending higher this year helped by relatively attractive valuations, ultra easy global monetary conditions and continuing moderate global economic growth.

Lower and lower bond yields point to a soft medium term return potential from them, but it’s hard to get too bearish in a world of fragile growth, spare capacity, low inflation and ongoing shocks like Brexit. That said, the recent bond rally has taken bond yields to ridiculously low levels leaving them at risk of a sharp snapback at some point.

 

Commercial property and infrastructure are likely to continue benefitting from the ongoing search for yield by investors.

Capital city dwelling price gains are expected to slow to around 3 percent over the year ahead, as the heat comes out of Sydney and Melbourne thanks to toughening lending standards and pockets of oversupply. Prices are likely to continue to fall in Perth and Darwin, but price growth may be picking up in Brisbane.

Cash and bank deposits offer poor returns.

While the Brexit outcome knocked the $A lower, it’s still higher than it should be and the longer term downtrend looks likely to continue as the interest rate differential in favour of Australia narrows as the RBA continues cutting and the Fed eventually resumes hiking, commodity prices remain in a secular downswing and the $A sees its usual undershoot of fair value. The $A is still likely to fall to around $US0.60 in the years ahead.

Eurozone shares lost 8.6 percent on Friday night and the US S&P 500 lost 3.6 percent in response to the Brexit vote. However, since the Australian share market largely responded to the Brexit outcome on Friday, ASX 200 futures actually rose 3 points or 0.1 percent indicating a basically flat start to trade for the Australian share market on Monday.